One of the things that we were planning to do while my parents were in Bermuda was have Aidan christened. We booked St. Peter’s church in St. George’s several months ago, and arranged to get together with the rector, the Reverend David Raths, the week before to discuss the details. But when we finally met him, things didn’t quite go to plan.
My main reason for wanting to meet was to discuss what my role in the ceremony would be. Mandy doesn’t believe in the Christian God, but she does believe in some kind of divine spirit. Because of that, and because she felt it was still “the done thing”, she wanted Aidan to be baptised. As an agnostic/atheist unwilling to promise to bring Aidan up as a Christian, however, I wanted to explore whether it would be possible to use an alternative form of words. I was hoping for something that would allow me to be involved in the service, but not compromise my beliefs.
When we met Rev. Raths, however, it was immediately apparent that the format of the ceremony was not up for discussion. As Mandy and I started to explain our religious beliefs (or lack of them), Rev. Raths listened with what seemed to me to be mounting horror. He seemed like a nice, quietly-spoken man, so when I had to look him in the eye and tell him I was an atheist I almost felt guilty, like I had insulted him personally. I told him that if I might be able to consider speaking the words in the ceremony and meaning them in a metaphorical sense, but that I couldn’t mean them literally. However, Rev. Raths was clearly unhappy with that.
I explained that I had no intention of bringing Aidan up to be a Christian exclusively and would be exposing him to all faiths and encouraging him to make up his own mind about them. I see nothing noble in promising to bring my child up according to the teachings of one particular faith. To me, that’s just indoctrination. Growing up in Bermuda, Aidan is already going to be exposed to enough of that. What I did want to know, however, was whether Aidan could get himself christened later in his life, if he chose to do so. Rev. Raths confirmed that he could.
Mandy did an excellent job explaining why she wanted a christening despite not being a Christian, and Rev. Raths was sympathetic. However, he stressed that a baptism was a very serious thing, “not just a photo opportunity”. Although he said he would perform the ceremony if we still wanted him to, it was clear that he would prefer not to.
Before we met Rev. Raths, Mandy had thought that he would welcome the opportunity to christen Aidan, despite our lack of faith, for Aidan’s sake. But during our chat it became clear that that was not how he felt at all. To him, a christening was about the parents pledging to bring the child up as a Christian, and if we knew in advance that we weren’t going to honour that pledge, he didn’t understand why we would want to make it. So in the end, we didn't.
More and more parents seem to be making a similar decision these days. Some of our friends who have babies have also decided not to have them christened, so Aidan will certainly not be unusual in this regard. And the more stories like this that I read, the more certain I am that we did absolutely the right thing.



